Item Coversheet

ALAMEDA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT
BOARD AGENDA ITEM


Item Title:Lum Advisory Committee Second Report and Recommendations Regarding Feasible Alternatives To Address Concerns Raised By Soil Test Results at Lum Elementary (15 Mins/Information)
Item Type:Information
Background:

At the request of some members of the Lum Community, the District has set aside time for presentation by a group of Lum parents/guardians. That group has submitted the following for Board and community consideration.

 

On April 26, 2017 the Alameda Unified School District publicly stated that there are possible unsafe building conditions at Lum Elementary in the event of a major earthquake, and is recommending that the AUSD Board vote to close the school and relocate students as of June 8, 2017. The Board is scheduled to vote on this recommendation on May 23, 2017.

 

Following the April 26th announcement, parents at Lum started our own District Advisory Committee (Lum DAC), in order to ensure safety and welfare of the Lum community, to work in cooperation with Board of Education and the AUSD, and to ensure the best possible solution for the entire AUSD and larger Alameda community.

 

In the weeks since we first learned that the AUSD was recommending closure and relocation of all 500+ Lum students to other AUSD schools, the Lum DAC has gathered together experts to help us assess the information upon which the AUSD is basing its recommendation. We will present additional findings, feasible alternatives to closure, and renew our demand that the Board delay closure so that true data and analysis can be completed and alternatives can be properly explored and considered.  This cannot remain a binary choice between just two options, to close Lum or leave it open. The Board MUST be allowed to vote on a 3rd option.

 

Lum DAC will present evidence and analysis in support of it’s demand and recommendation that the Board add a “3rd” voting option to the May 23, 2017 agenda, that would allow LUM TO REMAIN OPEN for the 2017-2018 school year, while further information, analysis and planning is conducted.

 

Presenters: Kelly Scott, Lum Advisory Committee, President Lum PTA;

Joe Keiser, Esq., Lum Advisory Committee;

Calvin Wong, former Director of Building Services, City Engineer, and Chief Building Official for City of Oakland;

Calin Smith, Structural Engineer;

John Grimaldi, SSFFD Captain

Submitted By: Joe Keiser, Esq., Lum Advisory Committee

 

Goals:
Fund:
Fund Codes: 
Fiscal Analysis

Amount (Savings) (Cost):


Department Budget:
Recommendation:Other
AUSD Guiding Principle:#1 - All students have the ability to achieve academic and personal success.| #4 - Parental involvement and community engagement are integral to student success.
Submitted By:Lum Advisory Committee (see above for name of person submitting)

ATTACHMENTS:
DescriptionUpload DateType
1 Certified Earthquake Safe5/19/2017Backup Material
2 2012 Assessment5/19/2017Backup Material
3 Seismic Eval Maya Lin5/19/2017Backup Material
4 washington report5/19/2017Backup Material
6 Loring Letter May 175/19/2017Backup Material
7 Wong Letter 5.8.175/19/2017Backup Material
8 Captain_John_Grimaldi_letter5/19/2017Backup Material
9 Architect's opinion on ZFA letter5/19/2017Backup Material
10 Tai Tang letter 5.4.175/19/2017Backup Material
11 section comparison5/19/2017Backup Material
12 Lum School Smith Engr. FINAL 5-14-17 r25/19/2017Backup Material
13 Smith FINAL 5-15-175/19/2017Backup Material
15 Questions to AUSD5/19/2017Backup Material
16 Preliminary Risk Analysis5/19/2017Backup Material
17 Detailed summary Lum DAC5/19/2017Backup Material
18 2017 Letter to AUSD - Opinions on Lum Elem Liquification concerns5/19/2017Backup Material
19 AUSD copy 25/19/2017Backup Material
20 Alameda parents fight to keep school open - San Francisco Chronicle5/19/2017Backup Material
21 Review of ZFA and Murphy Letters May 20175/19/2017Backup Material
5 Lum summary report scanned5/19/2017Backup Material
22 Petition5/19/2017Cover Memo